Rare 1937 Buffalo Nickel: In the world of rare coins, few stories have sparked as much fascination and speculation as the legendary 1937 Buffalo Nickel error. Touted by some collectors as potentially the most valuable coin ever minted, this mysterious coin is rumored to be worth up to $180 million yet it may still be hiding in someone’s pocket change or family coin jar.
But is this story fact or fiction? Let’s dive into the origin, mystery, and real-world value behind the infamous 1937 Buffalo Nickel error coin.
The Fascinating Backstory of the 1937 Buffalo Nickel Error
The Buffalo Nickel, officially called the Indian Head Nickel, was minted in the U.S. from 1913 to 1938. It features a proud Native American profile on the front (obverse) and a powerful American bison on the back (reverse). Designed by James Earle Fraser, this coin is one of the most iconic in American coinage.
But in 1937, something unusual reportedly happened at the Denver Mint a minting mishap so bizarre it’s been dubbed the “Three-Legged Perfect Mirrored Buffalo.”
What Makes This Error Coin So Unique?
Unlike the confirmed and collectible “Three-Legged Buffalo” error caused by excessive die polishing this legendary version is said to combine multiple rare errors in one coin:
- A missing front leg on the buffalo (similar to the Three-Legged variety)
- A dramatic die rotation (nearly 180 degrees)
- A double-die obverse with visible doubling on the date and letters
- A mirrored, proof-like finish (typically not found on circulation coins)
- A planchet with unusual silver content, unlike the standard copper-nickel alloy
Coin experts say that if such a coin really exists, it would represent a once-in-a-lifetime mistake—an anomaly that defies all odds.
“It would be like lightning striking the same place five times,” says Dr. Eleanor Richardson, curator at the National Numismatic Museum. “That’s what makes it so intriguing.”
Is the $180 Million Valuation Real?
The eye-popping $180 million price tag attached to this error coin has raised eyebrows. No coin has ever sold for that amount. For perspective:
- The most expensive coin ever sold: 1933 Double Eagle Gold Coin, auctioned for $18.9 million in 2021
- Most valuable nickel: 1913 Liberty Head V-Nickel, worth up to $5 million
So, where does the $180 million figure come from?
Factors Behind the Sky-High Valuation:
- Extreme Rarity: Only a few examples are rumored to exist possibly just one in private hands.
- Historical Significance: 1937 was among the final years of Buffalo Nickel production.
- Pristine Condition: The coin is reportedly in mint state, untouched by circulation.
- Mythical Status: Its story has taken on a life of its own, giving it “Holy Grail” status among collectors.
Claimed Sightings and Mysterious Appearances
Over the decades, several individuals have claimed to possess or encounter the coin, adding to its legend.
- 1977: Margaret Davidson from Tulsa said she found the coin in her father’s collection. It turned out to be a modified coin.
- 1982: Coin dealer Vincent Harlow claimed to authenticate a genuine example for a private collector who turned down an offer of $1.2 million.
- 2003: A coin resembling the description briefly appeared at a major coin convention before being pulled from display rumors swirled of a $40 million private offer.
While none of these claims have been independently verified, they continue to fuel speculation.
Real 1937 Buffalo Nickel Errors Worth Big Money
Even if the mythical $180 million version never turns up, there are real and valuable 1937 Buffalo Nickel errors you can look for:
✅ 1937-D Three-Legged Buffalo
- Caused by an over-polished die
- Sells for $1,000 to $50,000+, depending on condition
✅ 1937 Double-Die Obverse
- Visible doubling on the date and lettering
- Valued between $1,000 and $7,500
✅ 1937-D “D Over D” Repunched Mintmark
- Two visible Denver mintmarks stamped at different angles
- Worth $200 to $2,500
✅ Off-Center Strikes
- Part of the design is missing due to off-center striking
- Valued at $100 to $1,000+ depending on severity
How to Spot a Valuable 1937 Buffalo Nickel
Here’s what to look for if you’re hoping to find a valuable Buffalo Nickel in your collection:
- Check the Date: Focus on 1937 nickels, especially those with a “D” mintmark below “Five Cents” on the reverse.
- Look at the Legs: A missing front leg indicates the Three-Legged variety.
- Inspect for Doubling: Use a magnifying glass to check for double images on the date and lettering.
- Test for Rotation: Flip the coin vertically if the reverse isn’t aligned 180 degrees from the obverse, it may have a rotation error.
- Never Clean It: Cleaning a rare coin can ruin its value. Store it safely in a coin holder.
The Ongoing Hunt for the $180 Million Nickel
Despite skepticism, collectors and treasure hunters remain hopeful. The idea that such a coin could still be out there in a forgotten coin jar or inherited box adds excitement to the hobby.
“We still get people bringing in Buffalo Nickels, hoping it’s the one,” says Frank Miller, a coin dealer in Chicago. “Most aren’t, but every now and then, someone brings in something special.”
FAQs
1. What is the 1937 Buffalo Nickel error?
It’s a rumored rare coin with multiple minting mistakes, including a missing leg, die rotation, and proof-like finish.
2. Is the 1937 Buffalo Nickel error worth $300 million?
The value is speculative no such coin has officially sold, but its mythical status drives the estimated value.
3. How can I identify a valuable 1937 Buffalo Nickel?
Check for a missing buffalo leg, doubled lettering, rotation errors, and a Denver (“D”) mintmark.
4. Are there confirmed 1937 Buffalo Nickel errors?
Yes, the 1937-D Three-Legged Buffalo is a verified error and can sell for thousands.
5. Could the $300 million coin still be out there?
Possibly it may be hidden in old collections or jars, waiting to be discovered.
Final Thoughts: Is the 1937 Buffalo Nickel Error Real?
Whether myth or reality, the legend of the 1937 Buffalo Nickel Error continues to capture imaginations. It serves as a reminder of how history, craftsmanship, and a little bit of mystery can turn an everyday object into a national treasure.
So, the next time you’re sorting through old coins, don’t overlook that worn-out nickel. You never knowit could be worth more than you ever imagined.
Want to learn more about valuable coins and hidden treasures? Bookmark our site for the latest rare coin discoveries, price guides, and expert tips for U.S. collectors.
